Good Magic Nearly Pulled It Off At The Kentucky Derby. Nearly.

'saratoga living' Contributing Editor Mike Kane takes one last look at his Derby pick.

Kentucky Derby
Our Derby pick, Good Magic (No. 6 in yellow), came in second in the first leg of the 2018 Triple Crown, just behind the formidable winner, Justify. (Mike Kane)

For a few glorious seconds, as Good Magic reached the top of the stretch at the Kentucky Derby on May 5, trainer Chad Brown figured he’d captured the first Derby win of his career. Co-owner Bob Edwards of e Five Racing Thoroughbreds, a Derby rookie already possessing a remarkable record of racing success, did too. At the other end of the stretch, kneeling in front of four monitors on NBC Sports’ trackside set, I was having precisely the same reaction, though I certainly wasn’t screaming like Brown or Edwards. “Keep coming, keep coming,” I whispered as Good Magic moved a bit closer to front-running Justify, the unbeaten 5-2 favorite trained by Bob Baffert. “Keep coming.”

An instant or two later, Brown, Edwards and the millions of people watching at Churchill Downs and on TV realized that Good Magic wouldn’t be winning this race with destiny. Justify had responded to the challenge and spurted away on the track made a sloppy mess by nearly three inches of rain. Some 20 seconds later, Justify reached the finish line of the 144th Kentucky Derby, with a 2½-length victory over Good Magic.

Brown, the 39-year-old Mechanicville native building a Hall of Fame résumé, could’ve been bitter, but was remarkably upbeat afterward. “We’re working our way towards that Winner’s Circle,” he said. “It wasn’t meant to be this year. It was a tough field. But I’m real proud of this horse. He kept fighting all the way to the end and showed that he’s a top-class horse.” Jockey Jose Ortiz had followed Brown’s instructions and tracked Justify through fast early fractions. When the time came for the stalker to pounce, when many fast horses might’ve faltered, Justify had enough left.

The next morning, after checking on Good Magic, Brown smiled as I approached. “You almost got that right; I thought you did, picking us to win,” he said. I nodded and laughed, “Yeah, I was feeling it, too.” Back in January, saratoga living’s new Editor in Chief, Richard Pérez-Feria, asked me to pick the Derby winner in the year’s first issue. Though I realized, at that point, it’d be a fool’s errand, I agreed and went with Good Magic, co-owned by Edwards and his wife, Kris, a Saratoga Springs native. It wasn’t a longshot pick, because Good Magic was the 2017 two-year-old male champion, but precocious colts don’t always develop. Fortunately, Good Magic did.

Much like Brown, Edwards was disappointed, but satisfied. “Good Magic made the move, and Justify just made the move at the same time. He simply kept going. We didn’t have enough to catch him,” he said. “To run in your first Kentucky Derby, and to come in second, it’s still unbelievable.” I couldn’t agree more.

Mike Kane

Mike Kane is an award-winning journalist based in the Capital Region who has covered Saratoga Race Course for nearly 40 years. He spent 25 years as a sports writer and columnist at the Gazette Newspapers in Schenectady. Kane and Alan Carter are the co-authors of 150 Years of Racing in Saratoga.


Welcome to Saratoga Living, the premier lifestyle media company in Saratoga Springs and the heart of New York’s Capital Region.

Saratoga Living magazine publishes six times a year. saratogaliving.com relaunched on February 8, 2018. Like our page on Facebook, and follow us on Instagram and Twitter.

The Voux magazine theme




For Saratoga Living‘s Submission Guidelines,
click here.


All editorial queries should be directed to:
[email protected]; or sent to 6 Butler Place, Saratoga Springs, NY 12866.

Saratoga Living assumes no responsibility for unsolicited submissions.

For advertising inquiries, contact: [email protected].

For magazine subscriptions and to purchase back issues, contact:
[email protected].

For all other inquiries, call us at 518-294-4390.